• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Medicare Advantage vs Medicare Supplement (Medigap): Which Plan is Right for You?
January 4, 2024

Comparing Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement (Medigap) - two paths to healthcare coverage. Which one is right for you?

Medicare Advantage vs Supplement

Are you wondering which Medicare plan is right for you - Supplement or Advantage? Both plans have their advantages and disadvantages, so it's important to understand which one meets your healthcare needs better.

Medicare Supplement, also known as Medigap, is a private insurance plan that helps cover the out-of-pocket costs that Original Medicare doesn't pay for, such as deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance. With Medigap, you have the flexibility to choose your doctors and hospitals, as long as they accept Medicare.

In contrast, Medicare Advantage Part C is a government-sponsored plan offered by private insurance companies. This plan combines all the benefits of Original Medicare and often adds extra services such as vision, dental, and wellness programs. Medicare Advantage Part C plans usually have lower out-of-pocket costs than Medigap plans, but come with restrictions like needing to choose physicians within a network.

Pros and Cons of Medicare Coverage

Deciding between Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement (Medigap) can be a daunting task. To help you make an informed decision, let's take a look at the pros and cons of each plan. Understanding the advantages and disadvantages will empower you to choose the right coverage that best suits your healthcare needs and preferences. From flexibility and cost considerations to coverage options and restrictions, this overview will provide you with the essential information to navigate the Medicare landscape:

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Pros:

  • Provides more flexibility in choosing doctors and hospitals
  • Offers more standardized coverage options
  • Lower out-of-pocket costs for medical services and procedures

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Cons:

  • Requires a separate policy in addition to Original Medicare
  • Generally has higher monthly premiums
  • Doesn't include extra benefits like dental and vision care

Medicare Advantage Part C Pros:

  • Combines all the benefits of Original Medicare and often includes extra benefits like dental and vision care
  • Generally has lower monthly premiums
  • Offers a cap on out-of-pocket costs for medical services and procedures

Medicare Advantage Part C Cons:

When considering your options, it's important to weigh the pros and cons of both Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage Part C to find the plan that fits your healthcare needs best.

Conclusion:

Ultimately, the decision between Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage Part C depends on your individual healthcare needs. If you're looking for more comprehensive coverage and don't mind the restrictions, Medicare Advantage Part C might be the better choice. However, if you prefer more flexibility and lower costs for out-of-pocket expenses, Medigap might be the better option.

At Lehigh Partners, we can help you understand all your options so you can make an informed decision about your healthcare coverage. Contact us today for more information!

Telephone: (833) 265-9655

Get Help

Compare Medicare coverage options with the help of one of our agents:

Talk to us: (833) 265-9655 

Medicare Plan G Explained Simply (2025 Update)

When it comes to Medicare Supplement plans, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed by all the choices.If you’ve heard about Plan G but aren’t sure exactly what it covers – or whether it’s the right fit – you’re in the right place. Medicare Plan G is a popular Medicare Supplement plan in 2025 because it covers most

Read More

Top Mistakes People Make When Turning 65 (According to Reddit Users)

TL;DR – Top Medicare Mistakes to Avoid When Turning 65 Choosing a plan based only on the premium: $0 Medicare Advantage plans often come with hidden costs. Missing the Medigap open enrollment window: After 6 months, you could be denied or charged more. Thinking COBRA protects you: It doesn’t delay your need to enroll in

Read More

Plan G Is Not Cheap… But Here’s Why It Might Be the Best Deal in Healthcare

✅ TL;DR: Medigap Plan G offers the most comprehensive Medicare Supplement coverage available in 2025. It’s not the cheapest, but it helps you avoid surprise bills, see any doctor who accepts Medicare, and enjoy predictable healthcare costs. For many turning 65, it’s the safest long-term choice. Plan G costs how much?! Medicare decisions can feel

Read More

Medicare Mayhem: An Honest Look at Turning 65

It Starts the Way It Always Does…You’re turning 65. The mailbox is overflowing. Your phone won’t stop ringing. You can’t even watch Judge Judy without hearing about free flex cards and $0 premiums. Suddenly, you’re the most popular person in the Medicare universe.It’s not just confusing — it’s exhausting. Every flyer screams urgency. Every call promises savings.

Read More

Turning 65 Medicare: Avoid Costly Mistakes Now

Turning 65 Medicare: Choosing between Medicare Advantage and Medigap Plan G is a pivotal decision for individuals approaching 65. This guide aims to clarify both options, helping you make an informed choice tailored to your healthcare needs and financial situation.Medicare Plan Comparison Example: Meet Jane, Age 65If you’re turning 65 and trying to make sense

Read More

Medicare brokers such as Lehigh Partners get paid by the insurance companies they represent. And you pay exactly the same rate for your insurance if you use a Medicare consultant (broker). There is no extra fee or cost for enrolling through a broker. You will never pay a fee for our help.


Find a Plan

Shop for coverage online. Safe, Secure, & Confidential

Call us

Call Lehigh Partners at 1-833-265-9655

Licensed insurance agents are available to help you through enrollment and beyond.

Need Help?

Get in touch with a licensed sales agent now by filling out the form - no obligations!

Get Our FREE Medicare Checklist.

Download our complimentary Medicare checklist and conveniently access all the necessary information in one place, ensuring you never miss a crucial number, deadline, or date again.

Tags


Medicare Plan G Explained Simply (2025 Update)

When it comes to Medicare Supplement plans, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed by all the choices.If you’ve heard about Plan G but aren’t sure exactly what it covers – or whether it’s the right fit – you’re in the right place. Medicare Plan G is a popular Medicare Supplement plan in 2025 because it covers most

Read More

Top Mistakes People Make When Turning 65 (According to Reddit Users)

TL;DR – Top Medicare Mistakes to Avoid When Turning 65 Choosing a plan based only on the premium: $0 Medicare Advantage plans often come with hidden costs. Missing the Medigap open enrollment window: After 6 months, you could be denied or charged more. Thinking COBRA protects you: It doesn’t delay your need to enroll in

Read More

Medicare Mayhem: An Honest Look at Turning 65

It Starts the Way It Always Does…You’re turning 65. The mailbox is overflowing. Your phone won’t stop ringing. You can’t even watch Judge Judy without hearing about free flex cards and $0 premiums. Suddenly, you’re the most popular person in the Medicare universe.It’s not just confusing — it’s exhausting. Every flyer screams urgency. Every call promises savings.

Read More

Understanding Your Medicare Coverage Options

Understanding Your Medicare Coverage Options: Once you have enrolled in Part A (Hospital Insurance) and Part B (Medical Insurance) of Medicare, you have the flexibility to select the type of health coverage that best suits your needs.Option 1: Choosing Between Original Medicare and Medicare AdvantageWhen seeking Medicare coverage, there are two primary alternatives available to

Read More

Understanding Medicare: An Introduction

Part I: What is Medicare?Medicare is a health insurance program run by the government in the United States. It helps older people, some younger folks with disabilities, and people with severe kidney issues get medical coverage. Medicare started in 1965 to make sure people have access to the healthcare they need.The History of MedicareMedicare became

Read More

The 4 Most Common Medigap Plans and Who They Are For

Medicare Supplement Plans, also known as Medigap plans, are health insurance policies offered by private insurers to help cover some of the costs that Original Medicare does not pay for. There are several standardized Medigap plans available, with the four most common ones being Plans G, N, F, and C. Each plan offers different levels

Read More

Ready to talk to an agent about your Medicare coverage?