Choosing your health care in retirement is a big decision, and not an easy one. One topic of confusion for people is if they should choose a Medicare Advantage plan or stick with Original Medicare and pick up a Medicare Supplement plan.
Medicare Advantage vs. Medicare Supplement Comparison
Here are some things to help you decide if Medicare Supplement is a smart choice for you.
Medicare Supplement | Medicare Advantage | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Doctor and Hospital Choice | You can use any doctor or hospital that takes Medicare, anywhere in the U.S. This means if you are traveling and need care, you’re covered. In most cases, you don’t need a referral to use a specialist. | In many cases, you can only use doctors and other providers who are in the plan’s network and service area (for non-emergency care). You may need to get a referral to use a specialist. | ||
Cost | You pay a premium. Medicare Supplement plans generally help pay the gaps in your Medicare coverage. | |||
Coverage | In most cases, you don’t have to get a service or supply approved ahead of time. You can choose your own Medicare drug coverage (Part D) to suit your needs. | In many cases, you may need to get approval from your plan before it covers certain drugs or services. Many include Medicare drug coverage, which is standardized for everyone in the plan. | ||
If you choose Medicare Supplement, you may pay a little more in premiums but gain the ability to choose your own:*
doctors
specialists
prescription drug coverage
*With a Medicare Supplement, you can receive treatment from any Medicare-approved doctor or specialist.
1. “What You’ll Pay in Out-of-Pocket Medicare Costs in 2024”, National Council on Aging, 10/13/23.
The Medicare Decision That Matters More Than You ThinkIf you’re turning 65 soon, I don’t need to tell you that your mailbox has probably turned into a war zone of Medicare ads. Shiny brochures. Friendly-looking seniors. Confusing charts. And somehow… nobody’s giving you a straight answer. Here’s what I’ve learned after helping people with Medicare for over
Read MoreWhen it comes to Medicare Supplement plans, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed by all the choices.If you’ve heard about Plan G but aren’t sure exactly what it covers – or whether it’s the right fit – you’re in the right place. Medicare Plan G is a popular Medicare Supplement plan in 2025 because it covers most
Read MoreTL;DR – Top Medicare Mistakes to Avoid When Turning 65 Choosing a plan based only on the premium: $0 Medicare Advantage plans often come with hidden costs. Missing the Medigap open enrollment window: After 6 months, you could be denied or charged more. Thinking COBRA protects you: It doesn’t delay your need to enroll in
Read More✅ TL;DR: Medigap Plan G offers the most comprehensive Medicare Supplement coverage available in 2025. It’s not the cheapest, but it helps you avoid surprise bills, see any doctor who accepts Medicare, and enjoy predictable healthcare costs. For many turning 65, it’s the safest long-term choice. Plan G costs how much?! Medicare decisions can feel
Read MoreThe $1,200 Wake-Up CallA few years back, I got a call from a woman named Janet who had just retired after 40 years in education. She was sharp, organized, and had always handled her benefits like a pro. But that call wasn’t a happy one.She was sitting at the pharmacy counter, trying to pick up
Read MoreIt Starts the Way It Always Does…You’re turning 65. The mailbox is overflowing. Your phone won’t stop ringing. You can’t even watch Judge Judy without hearing about free flex cards and $0 premiums. Suddenly, you’re the most popular person in the Medicare universe.It’s not just confusing — it’s exhausting. Every flyer screams urgency. Every call promises savings.
Read MoreCall us
Call Lehigh Partners at 1-833-265-9655
Licensed insurance agents are available to help you through enrollment and beyond.
Tags
When it comes to Medicare Supplement plans, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed by all the choices.If you’ve heard about Plan G but aren’t sure exactly what it covers – or whether it’s the right fit – you’re in the right place. Medicare Plan G is a popular Medicare Supplement plan in 2025 because it covers most
Read MoreTL;DR – Top Medicare Mistakes to Avoid When Turning 65 Choosing a plan based only on the premium: $0 Medicare Advantage plans often come with hidden costs. Missing the Medigap open enrollment window: After 6 months, you could be denied or charged more. Thinking COBRA protects you: It doesn’t delay your need to enroll in
Read MoreThe $1,200 Wake-Up CallA few years back, I got a call from a woman named Janet who had just retired after 40 years in education. She was sharp, organized, and had always handled her benefits like a pro. But that call wasn’t a happy one.She was sitting at the pharmacy counter, trying to pick up
Read MoreIt Starts the Way It Always Does…You’re turning 65. The mailbox is overflowing. Your phone won’t stop ringing. You can’t even watch Judge Judy without hearing about free flex cards and $0 premiums. Suddenly, you’re the most popular person in the Medicare universe.It’s not just confusing — it’s exhausting. Every flyer screams urgency. Every call promises savings.
Read MoreUnderstanding Your Medicare Coverage Options: Once you have enrolled in Part A (Hospital Insurance) and Part B (Medical Insurance) of Medicare, you have the flexibility to select the type of health coverage that best suits your needs.Option 1: Choosing Between Original Medicare and Medicare AdvantageWhen seeking Medicare coverage, there are two primary alternatives available to
Read MorePart I: What is Medicare?Medicare is a health insurance program run by the government in the United States. It helps older people, some younger folks with disabilities, and people with severe kidney issues get medical coverage. Medicare started in 1965 to make sure people have access to the healthcare they need.The History of MedicareMedicare became
Read MoreIn today’s population, many baby boomers are reaching retirement age and enrolling in Medicare to ensure comprehensive healthcare coverage. As more and more of this demographic seeks quality healthcare options, interest in Medicare Advantage plans – commonly known as Part C of Medicare – has seen a significant uptick. Understanding the basic features and benefits
Read MoreMedicare Supplement Plans, also known as Medigap plans, are health insurance policies offered by private insurers to help cover some of the costs that Original Medicare does not pay for. There are several standardized Medigap plans available, with the four most common ones being Plans G, N, F, and C. Each plan offers different levels
Read More